Home Collections Very Best Sellers

Very Best Sellers

Our best sellers. Whether you're looking for a gift, stocking up on jam or hot sauce, or just trying something new, you're sure to find a winner here. 
Cherry Bomb Hot Sauce
from $6.00
Bloody Mary Gift Set
$45.00
Wisconsin Sausage and Cheese Gift Box - Farm to Table, Artisan Made Quality Meats
$59.95
B&P's Hot Sauce Rainbow Six Pack - Nick's Picks
$32.00
Custom Selection - Three Pack Hot Sauce Set
$20.00
B&P's Fiesta Favorites! Hot Sauce Trio - Small Batch Handmade Hot Sauce Gift Box Cherry Bomb, Better Sriracha, Smokey Dokey
$20.00
Three Pack of B&P Jam - Custom Selection
$25.00
Limited Edition B&P 2024 Holiday Jam
$8.00
Limited Edition NEW 2024 Christmas Jam
$8.00
Cherry Lavender Jam
$8.00
Strawberry Rhubarb Jam
$8.00
Raspberry Habanero Jam
$8.00
B&P Cafe Classics- Hot Sauce Rainbow Six Pack - Small Batch Handmade Hot Sauces
$32.00
Ghost Pepper Hot Sauce - The Ghost Pepper Trinity! Holy Ghost, Friendly Ghost and Golden Ghost
$20.00
Custom Selection - Six Pack Hot Sauce Set
$32.00
B&P's Small Batch Handmade Pickled Beets - Three Jars
$27.00
A full case of Cherry Bomb Hot Sauce - Our Best Seller - Case of 12
$70.00
Wisconsin's Favorite Pickle: Dilly Beans!- Three Jars
$24.00